Immigration Law Wiki
Tag - asylum
Articles
You may have heard of cases where the Court pretermit a respondent’s application and ordered them removed before they even had their individual hearing. This is something that can happen if you do not submit a complete application that states a valid claim for relief that is supported by the required evidence. This has always existed but it has become much more common under the current administration due to their aggressive immigration policies as well as some recent case regarding pretermission such as Matter of C-A-R-R-, 29 I&N Dec. 13 (BIA 2025) and Matter of H-A-A-V-, 29 I&NDec. 233 (BIA 2025). Since April 2025 Immigration judges have been explicitly encouraged to pretermit asylum applications as the Executive Office for Immigration Review (EOIR) issued Policy Memorandum 25-28, Pretermission of Legally Insufficient Applications for Asylum. What is a Motion to Pretermit? A motion to pretermit is a motion that the Department of Homeland Security can file with the Immigration Court, asking that the Judge essentially deny your application for relief without having a trial because based on the information provided in the application the respondent cannot possibly establish their eligibility for the relief being sought. The reason so many cases are pretermit is because many people do not provide enough details in their application to prove their case. The Board’s decision in Matter of H-A-A-V-, 29 I&N Dec. 233 (BIA 2025) held that Immigration Judges may pretermit applications where the respondent has not established prima facie eligibility for asylum, withholding of removal, or protection under the Convention Against Tortureâeven when viewing the application in the light most favorable to the respondent. The decision rests on the premise that a hearing is required only when there is a factual dispute that must be resolved. This is why it is more important than ever that applicants for asylum make sure that they provide detailed answers to all of the questions on the Form I-589 and provide a very detailed personal statement describing the facts surrounding their asylum claim. As well as explaining all the harm previously suffered or the reasons for the respondent’s fear of future harm, the respondent must be sure to provide articulate a clear nexus to a legally cognizable protected ground and, where the persecutor is a non-state actor, establishing that the government is unable or unwilling to provide protection. Of course, they must also address any potential asylum bars and why they do not apply in their case. Asylum Cooperative Agreements (“ACAs”) Pretermission is an extremely difficult hurdle if your case is subject to any Asylum Cooperative Agreements (“ACAs”). The first Trump administration entered into ACAs with El Salvador, Guatemala, and Honduras. The current Trump administration has pursued ACAs with Belize, Ecuador, Guatemala, Honduras, Paraguay and Uganda while future ACAs with additional countries are anticipated. These ACAs, according to the Government, give this administration the ability to remove individuals from any country with an executed ACA if they entered the United States at a port of entry without a visa, or if they entered without inspection between ports of entry, on or after November 19, 2019, without having to give them an asylum hearing The ACAs are agreements that say the US can send asylum applicants from these countries to anyone of the participating countries and that country will give them an asylum hearing so the US does not have to. There are very limited exceptions that are almost impossible to invoke. The BIA has upheld their authority to do this in Matter of C-I-G-M- & L-V-S-G-, 29 I&N Dec. 291 (BIA 2025). The BIA also emphasized that immigration judges lack authority to decide whether the third country offers a âfull and fairâ asylum process or whether it is in the âpublic interestâ to allow the respondent to apply for asylum in the United States. Those determinations are reserved to DHS and the Attorney General under 8 C.F.R. § 1240.11(h). Matter of C-I-G-M- & L-V-S-G- reframes ACA pretermission as a mandatory threshold screening inquiry. If a respondent cannot establish that an ACA exception applies, such as by demonstrating, under the âmore-likely-than-notâ standard, a risk of persecution or torture in the designated third country, the immigration judge must pretermit the asylum application without holding an individual hearing or addressing the merits of the claim. The Judge may simply determine that the ACA applies and enter an order of removal to that third country. Incomplete Applications An application may also be pretermit for being incomplete. Under 8 C.F.R. § 1208.3(c)(3),21 an asylum application is incomplete if it does not include a response to each of the questions contained in Form I-589, is unsigned, or is unaccompanied by the required materials. The regulations specify that an incomplete application must be returned to the applicant and â[a]n application returned to the applicant as incomplete shall be resubmitted by the applicant with the additional information if he or she wishes to have the application considered. Even more significantly, 8 C.F.R. § 1208.3(c)(3) goes on to say, â[i]f the Service has not mailed the incomplete application back to the applicant within 30 days, it shall be deemed complete.â (Emphasis added). The Pretermission Memo does not cite this regulation at all and Matter of C-A-R-R-, which does cite the regulation including this language, does not discuss the âdeemed completeâ section of the regulation. The immigration judge cannot simply reject an applicantâs application based on an analysis that the applicant has not made a prima facie case for the relief sought. Such reasoning is in violation of the immigration statute, applicable BIA precedential case law, and contrary to the due process protections in the United States Constitution. The Government is saying that they can and ignoring the law. How Pretermission Violates the Law Pretermission as a practice likely violates the U.S. Constitution, the Immigration and Nationality Act (INA), regulations, and binding precedent which require EOIR to allow asylum seekers to testify in support of their applications. For over 100 years, the Supreme Court has recognized the special
During President Trump’s first term the U.S. signed âasylum cooperative agreementsâ with El Salvador, Guatemala, and Honduras (âthe Northern Triangle countriesâ) that allow the U.S. to send asylum seekers to these countries and bar them from applying for protection in the U.S. You can see more about the original implementation of these agreements on the DHS website. The Biden administration suspended these agreements once he took office but then Trump was elected to second term as president and on July 2025, DHS published in the Federal Register the âAgreement Between the Government of the United States of America and the Government of the Republic of Honduras for Cooperation in the Examination of Protection Requests.â The agreement provides for Honduras to process protection requests, such as for asylum or temporary protection, for some “protection applicantsâ the U.S. Government sends to Honduras after they request protection in the U.S. The agreement does not apply to nationals of Honduras, stateless habitual residents of Honduras, unaccompanied minors, or people who arrived in the U.S. with a valid visa or visa waiver (90 FR 30076, 7/8/25). The full text of the Federal Register is below. The Board of Immigration Appeals has issued a decision in Matter of C-I-G-M- & L-V-S-G-, 29 I&N Dec. 291 (BIA 2025) regarding these agreements. The Board’s decision was: (1) If the Department of Homeland Security claims that an asylum cooperative agreement bars a respondent from applying for asylum in the United States, the Immigration Judge should determine whether the safe third country bar applies prior to and separate from considering a respondentâs eligibility for asylum. (2) A respondent subject to the terms of an asylum cooperative agreement has the burden to establish by a preponderance of the evidence that he or she will more likely than not be persecuted on account of a protected ground or tortured in the relevant third country to avoid application of the safe third country bar and for the respondent to be eligible to seek asylum and other protection claims in the United States. âAgreement Between the Government of the United States of America and the Government of the Republic of Honduras for Cooperation in the Examination of Protection Requests.â
ONE YEAR PHYSICAL PRESENCE REQUIREMENT USCIS announced the policy change last year and I didn’t see it. POLICY UPDATE FOR ASYLEE ADJUSTMENT OF STATUS Asylees do not have to wait a year to file an I-485 because USCIS will now count the year from the date of adjudication of the I-485 not its filing date. REFERENCES USCIS Policy Manual Chapter 2 USCIS Policy Manual Volume 7 Part A 8 CFR 11771 Title 8 Section 1159 REQUIREMENTS TO ADJUST STATUS According to the USCIS Policy Manual, Volume 7 â Adjustment of Status, Part M â Asylee Adjustment, an asylee may adjust their status to a lawful permanent resident if they meet the following four requirements: â
1 year physical presence in the US after being granted asylum â
Continuing to meet the definition of a refugee or being the spouse/child of the principal asylee â
Not having firmly resettled in a foreign country â
Admissible to the US as an immigrant at the time of adjustment of status examination The first and foremost requirement for Asylees to be eligible for a green card is to have been physically present in the US for at least 1 year after being granted asylum. This requirement is crucial in determining the eligibility of an asylee for a green card. đ The recent update from USCIS regarding the requirement for Asylees and Refugees to have a physical presence in the United States for a full year prior to filing for a Green Card has caused some confusion among immigration lawyers. Some interpret this update as a change in policy, allowing Asylees to file for a Green Card after only several months of physical presence in the US, while others believe that the one year requirement still holds. Itâs important to note that, according to USCIS policy, an Asylee must have been physically present in the United States for at least one year after being granted asylum in order to be eligible for Adjustment of Status to a Lawful Permanent Resident (LPR). Despite this, there seems to be some uncertainty surrounding the new USCIS rule and its potential impact on the timeline for Asylees to apply for a Green Card. Until further clarification from USCIS, it remains a point of debate among immigration lawyers. Some believe that Asylees should still wait the full year before filing for a Green Card, while others think that the shortened time frame is acceptable. In either case, it is crucial for Asylees to consult with an experienced immigration lawyer to understand their options and ensure they are following all the necessary steps in their Green Card asylum journey. See Matter of Chawathe (PDF), 25 I&N Dec. 369, 376 (AAO 2010). Certain documentation requirements do not apply to asylees adjusting status. See INA 212(a)(7)(A). Matter of Chawathe (1) For purposes of establishing the requisite continuous residence in naturalization proceedings pursuant to section 316(b) of the Immigration and Nationality Act, 8 U.S.C. § 1427(b) (2006), a publicly held corporation may be deemed an âAmerican firm or corporationâ if the applicant establishes that the corporation is both incorporated in the United States and trades its stock exclusively on U.S. stock exchange markets. (2) When an applicantâs employer is a publicly held corporation that is incorporated in the United States and trades its stock exclusively on U.S. stock markets, the applicant need not demonstrate the nationality of the corporation by establishing the nationality of those persons who own more than 51% of the stock of that firm. Matter of Warrach, 17 I&N Dec. 285, 286-87 (Reg. Commâr 1979), clarified. (3) In most administrative immigration proceedings, the applicant must prove by a preponderance of evidence that he or she is eligible for the benefit sought. (4) Even if the director has some doubt as to the truth, if the petitioner submits relevant, probative, and credible evidence that leads the director to believe that the claim is âmore likely than notâ or âprobablyâ true, the applicant has satisfied the standard of proof. Matter of E-M-, 20 I&N Dec. 77, 79-80 (Commâr 1989), followed. (5) If the director can articulate a material doubt, it is appropriate for the director to either request additional evidence or, if that doubt leads the director to believe that the claim is probably not true, deny the application or petition. PREPONDERANCE OF EVIDENCE Except where a different standard is specified by law, a petitioner or applicant in administrative immigration proceedings must prove by a preponderance of evidence that he or she is eligible for the benefit sought. See, e.g., Matter of Martinez, 21 I&N Dec. 1035, 1036 (BIA 1997) (noting that the petitioner must prove eligibility by a preponderance of evidence in visa petition proceedings); Matter of Soo Hoo, 11 I&N Dec. 151, 152 (BIA 1965) (finding that the petitioner had not established eligibility by a preponderance of the evidence because the submitted evidence was not credible); cf. Matter of Patel, 19 I&N Dec. 774, 782-3 (BIA 1988) (noting that section 204(a)(2)(A) of the Act, 8 U.S.C. § 1154(a)(2)(A) (Supp. IV 1986), requires a higher standard of clear and convincing evidence to rebut the presumption of a fraudulent prior marriage). See more info at the BURDEN OF PROOF â PREPONDERANCE OF EVIDENCE page.
The requirements for asylum, withholding of removal, and protection under Article III of the UN Convention Against Torture (“CAT”) compared. Withholding Under the INA & Withholding Under CAT There is actually withholding of removal under INA §241(b)(3) and withholding of removal under CAT. Withholding under INA §241(b)(3) gives the applicant the burden of proving that his/her life or freedom would be threatened in the proposed country of removal on account of race, religion, nationality, membership in a particular social group, or political opinion. Withholding of removal under CAT does not require there to be a nexus between the harm and a protected ground (race, religion, nationality, political opinion, or membership in a particular social group). Most people say “withholding of removal” when referring to withholding of removal under INA 241(b)(3) and then combine withholding of removal under CAT and deferral of removal under CAT referring to both of them as “protections under CAT.” That is exactly what I’ve done here, so Primary Distinctions Between Asylum, Withholding, & CAT Withholding of removal is a higher standard than asylum despite granting fewer benefits, but it is not subject to the one-year filing deadline. A noncitizen who fails to establish reasonable possibility of persecution for asylum (a 10% chance can be sufficient) will not be able to establish eligibility for withholding since it is a higher burden of more likely than not (greater than 50% chance). CAT does not require that the persecution be based on a protected ground and requires the same likelihood of harm as withholding of removal, which is more likely than not ( or > 50% chance). However, for CAT the harm must meet the definition of torture. – ASYLUM WITHHOLDING CAT PROTECTION ONE-YEAR FILING DEADLINE Yes No No TYPE OF HARM Persecution Threat to life or freedom Torture LIKELIHOOD OF HARM Reasonable Possibility (A 10% chance can be sufficient) More likely than not (greater than 50% chance of occurrence) More likely than not > 50% chance NEXUS REQUIREMENT Yes–Persecution must be a central reason for the harm. Yes–Harm must be based on the protected ground. No nexus requirement. WHO IS INFLICTINGTHE HARM The Government or a non-government actor the government is unable or unwilling to control. The Government or a non-government actor the government is unable or unwilling to control. The Government or any person acting at the instigation of or with the consent or acquiescence of a public official Discretionary Yes (the Judge can deny as a matter of discretion even if you met the requirements of the statute). No. No. Reinstated removal order Bar to Asylum No bar. No bar. Criminal Bars Aggravated felony, Particularly Serious Crime,Serious nonpolitical crime bar Particularly Serious Crime, Serious nonpolitical crime bar No. This chart lacks details and exceptions that may exist under the law. There are other criminal bars and security bars to all of these forms of relief that are not listed here. Please check the statutes and regulations. Asylum, Withholding of Removal, Convention Against Torture. Footnotes:
A principal refugee admitted to the United States within the past 2 years or a principal asylee who was granted asylum within the past 2 years, may use the Form I-730 to petition for a spouse or child. Petitioning in this context meaning to request that a spouse or an unmarried child under 21 years of age join the principal asylee in the United States. In certain circumstances, unmarried adult sons/daughters over 21 years of age may be eligible for following-to-join immigration benefits if they fall within the protections set forth in the Child Status Protection Act. In some cases, USCIS may grant a waiver of the 2-year filing deadline for humanitarian reasons as explained in the Instructions for Form I-730. Catholic Legal Immigration Network, Inc. made a guide for Form I-730 that you can find here. Just keep in mind that the guide is from 2019 and there have been some changes to policy and procedure since then. Double check the USCIS website to make sure you read the information on the USCIS I-730 information page. Also, a link to the official USCIS instructions is provided below. Form Instructions I-730 FILLABLE I-730 LEARN MORE
Matter of H-C-R-C-, 28 I&N Dec. 809 (BIA 2024) (1) Applicants bear the burden of establishing their own credibility, and no statute or legal precedent compels an Immigration Judge to conclude that an applicantâs testimony is credible. (2) Rape is sufficiently severe to constitute torture and can never be a lawful sanction under the Convention Against Torture.
Fear interviews are part of the expedited removal process. When a person is put into the expedited removal process, if they express a fear of returning to their home country or request to seek asylum, they are first screened to see if they could establish that they have a fear of persecution or torture. Generally speaking, there are two âlevelsâ of fear interviews, most commonly referred to as âcredible fearâ and âreasonable fear.â A person is said to have a âcredible fearâ if they can demonstrate a âsignificant possibilityâ that they will be able to establish eligibility for asylum or withholding of removal under the Immigration and Nationality Act or withholding of removal or deferral of removal under the Convention Against Torture. A person establishing a âreasonable fearâ of persecution or torture has to demonstrate a higher likelihood that they would be eligible for relief from removal. The fear screening process has been periodically altered by new rules issued by various presidential administrations. Those rules are also often the subject of litigation, making the exact process an individual is subjected to (including the standard of proof needed to establish a âcredibleâ fear) subject to regular change. Additionally, many of the rules are applied only to a subset of individuals, often seemingly at random, due to changing logistical, diplomatic, or humanitarian factors. Therefore, the credible and reasonable fear interview process may be applied differently to different people depending on things such as when they arrived at the border, where they arrived, what country they arrived from, whether they entered at a port of entry or between ports of entry, and other considerations. At the credible or reasonable fear interview, if an individual is found by the asylum officer to have met the standard applied to them, they are then referred to proceedings where they can submit an application for asylum or other similar protections. Usually, this is done via a referral to an immigration court, where a person is put in removal proceedings initiated with a Notice to Appear. Some pilot programs such as that created by the Asylum Processing Rule created an alternative venue, where people would have their full asylum cases reviewed by an asylum officer rather than an immigration judge, on a significantly truncated timeline. If the asylum officer determines the person did not establish either credible or reasonable fear, their expedited removal order stays in place. Before removal, the individual may request review of the fear determination by an immigration judge. If the immigration judge overturns a negative fear finding, the individual is treated as if they passed their fear interview and is placed in further removal proceedings through which the individual can seek protection from removal, including asylum. If the immigration judge upholds the negative finding by the asylum officer, the individual will be removed from the United States. In Fiscal Year (FY) 2023 (a year in which the Title 42 pandemic border expulsion policy was in effect for eight out of 12 months), USCIS found 53,965 individuals to have credible fear. These individuals, many of whom were detained during this screening process, will be afforded an opportunity to apply for asylum defensively and establish that they meet the refugee definition. The number of credible fear cases has skyrocketed since the procedure was implementedâin FY 2009, USCIS completed 5,523 cases. Case completions reached an all-time high in FY 2023 at 148,440. In FY 2023, two-thirds of which occurred during Title 42, USCIS found 1,950 individuals to have reasonable fear.
Well-founded Fear of Persecution Definition of Persecution Although persecution is not specifically defined within the INA, the courts have held that âa threat to life or freedom on account of race, religion, nationality, political opinion or membership of a particular social group is always persecution.â  The United Nations High Commission on Refugees (UNHCR) has endorsed a similar standard in its Handbook on Procedures and Criteria for Determining Refugee Status under the 1951 Convention and the 1967 Protocol Relating to the Status of Refugees.  Persecution has also frequently been defined as âthe infliction of suffering or harm upon those who differ in a way regarded as offensive.â Persecution is usually physical but can also be emotional or psychological. Recognizing persecution is extremely fact-dependent and fact-specific. Although asylum adjudicators will determine what constitutes persecution on a case-by-case basis, they have consistently recognized certain types of behavior as persecution. The following five broad categories describe abuse that adjudicators may find rise to the level of persecution: Serious Physical Harm The most recognized form of persecution is the infliction of serious physical harm, including confinement, kidnapping, torture, and beatings.  Rape, sexual assault and other forms of gender-based violence are also persecution. The rape and beating of an LGBTQ/H person on account of their sexual orientation, gender identity, and/or HIV status constitutes persecution. Many LGBTQ individuals have been raped or sexually assaulted as âpunishmentâ for their sexual orientation or gender identity. In the case of Hernandez-Montiel, the Ninth Circuit found that there was persecution when a âgay man with a female sexual identityâ was detained, strip-searched, sexually assaulted, and raped by police officers on more than one occasion and sexually assaulted and attacked by a group of men. Threats of violence will generally not be sufficient to establish past persecution unless the threats themselves cause significant harm. âThreats standing aloneâŠconstitute persecution in only a small category of cases and only when the threats are so menacing as to cause significant actual suffering or harm.â link Threats will be more likely to establish future persecution if the applicant can demonstrate that the group who is making the threats has the will and ability to carry them out. link Female genital mutilation (FGM) is also a form of persecution. Although the threat of FGM in the future can demonstrate a well-founded fear of persecution, a recent Ninth Circuit case has held that genital mutilation is an ongoing act of persecution âwhich cannot constitute a change in circumstances sufficient to rebut the presumption of a well-founded fear.â link Thus, both past FGM and the threat of having the procedure can be the basis for a well-founded fear of persecution. Violence against an applicantâs family members can also support a case for asylum. Coercive Medical and Psychological Treatment Certain types of medical and psychological treatment will demonstrate a well-founded fear of persecution. The Board of Immigration Appeals has found that âforced institutionalization, electroshock treatments and drug injections could constitute persecution.â The coercive family planning practiced by the Chinese government may also constitute persecution. The most significant holding in this area is the Ninth Circuit decision in Pitcherskaia v. INS. 21 Pitcherskaia, a lesbian from Russia, was arrested and imprisoned on several occasions for protesting violence and discrimination against gays and lesbians in Russia. The militia threatened her with forced institutionalization and required her to attend therapy sessions. She was prescribed sedative medication which she successfully refused. In addition, an ex-girlfriend of hers was institutionalized against her will and was subjected to electric shock treatment and other treatments meant to âcureâ her of her sexual orientation. The Ninth Circuit ruled that it is not necessary for the persecutor to intend harm in order for unwanted medical or psychological treatment to amount to persecution, as long as the victim experiences the treatment as harmful. The proper test is whether or not a reasonable person would have found the suffering inflicted as offensive. There have also been successful non-precedential Convention Against Torture claims for individuals living with HIV who were able to demonstrate that they would be incarcerated in sub-standard conditions if returned to their home countries. Finding that such incarceration would like lead to death, at least two Immigration Judges (IJs) have granted CAT under these circumstances. Invidious Prosecution or Disproportionate Punishment for a Criminal Offense Asylum status will not be granted for criminal prosecution as a result of a violation of a fairly administered law. Prosecution may be considered persecution, however, if there is either severe punishment or pretextual prosecution. Asylum adjudicators will focus on whether the punishment under a countryâs laws is disproportionately severe or whether the law or punishment is contrary to international human rights standards. Economic Persecution and Other Forms of Severe Discrimination Generally, harassment and discrimination will not constitute persecution. Persecution is regarded as an extreme concept that differs from general discrimination against minority groups, link which requires âmore than a few isolated incidents of verbal harassment or intimidation, unaccompanied by any physical punishment, infliction of harm, or significant deprivation of liberty.â link Severe forms of discrimination may however amount to persecution in some instances. Discrimination will amount to persecution âif measures of discrimination lead to consequences of a substantially prejudicial nature for the person concerned, e.g. serious restrictions on his right to earn his livelihood, his right to practice his religion, or his access to normally available educational facilities.â link Cumulative discrimination that is increasing in severity will have a higher chance of being considered persecution. For instance, the inability to travel safely within a country and forced expulsion from the country amount to persecution. One form of severe discrimination recognized by the courts is in the form of economic persecution. Economic persecution requires a probability of deliberate imposition of substantial economic disadvantage based on a protected ground. Severe discrimination may be a ground for applicants living with HIV to claim asylum. The discrimination, however, must go beyond inadequate medical treatment. In one unpublished decision, an IJ found that a married woman living with HIV would be subject to persecution on account of severe discrimination. 39 In making this decision, the IJ considered documentary evidence that people living with HIV lost their jobs when
+ 3 Articles
Show More