Immigration Law Wiki
-
Basic Information
-
Immigration Court
-
Permanent Residency
-
Nonimmigrant Visas
-
Other Visas
-
Citizenship
- Citizenship Interview Resources
- How to Check Your Selective Service Registration
- N-400 FILING FEE, FEE WAIVER, OR FEE REDUCTION REQUEST
- N-400, Application for Naturalization
- Preparing for Civics Examination for Naturalization
- USCIS Provides Policy Update Regarding Acquisition of Citizenship Provisions
-
FAQs
- Can I Travel Once My U Visa is Approved?
- DACA
- Family Reunification Parole Processes (FRPP)
- Family Reunification Parole Processes (FRPP)
- Hiring A Noncitizen to Work in the U.S.
- How to Check Your Selective Service Registration
- How to Get a Taxpayer Identification Number
- How to Pay USCIS Filing Fee With a Credit Card
- How To Write A Cover Letter To USCIS
- I-864, Affidavit of Support
- ICE Check-In
- Right to be Put Into Removal Proceedings to Seek Relief
- Tax Identification Number (TIN)
- What If I Missed My Hearing?
- Who is a "child" for Immigration Purposes?
- Show More (3) Collapse
-
Guides
-
Asylum
-
USCIS
- 2024 HHS Poverty Guidelines
- Asylee Petition for Spouse and/or Child, Form I-730
- Class of Admission Codes
- Family Reunification Parole Processes (FRPP)
- How to Pay USCIS Filing Fee With a Credit Card
- How To Write A Cover Letter To USCIS
- I-864, Affidavit of Support
- Immigration Medical Examination and Vaccination Record
- N-400 FILING FEE, FEE WAIVER, OR FEE REDUCTION REQUEST
- PAROLE-IN-PLACE FOR SPOUES OF US CITIZENS
- VAWA
-
Reference
-
Criminal Consequences
-
Immigrant Visas
-
Visa Waivers
-
Conditional Residency
-
Other
-
Adjustment of Status
-
Parole
NY CONTROLLED SUBSTANCE OFFENSES
The Second Circuit has found that NY defines narcotic in a way that is overbroad and includes substances that are not on the federally controlled substance schedules and therefore, under the categorical approach, are not controlled substance offenses.
U.S. v. Minter, No. 21-3102 (2d Cir. 2023)
The issue on appeal is whether Defendant’s 2014 conviction under New York Penal Law Section 220.39(1) for the sale of cocaine was for a “serious drug offense” and therefore qualifies as a predicate offense for the purposes of a sentencing enhancement under the ACCA.
The Second Circuit affirmed, holding that New York’s definition of cocaine is categorically broader than its federal counterpart, thus, Defendant’s cocaine conviction cannot serve as a predicate ACCA offense. The government argued that under Gonzalez v. Duenas-Alvarez, that even if the New York definition of cocaine is broadly construed to criminalize all its isomers, Minter must show a “realistic probability, not a theoretical possibility,” that New York’s statute is broader in practice. The court explained that here, the New York statute applies on its face to all cocaine isomers; the CSA does not. In citing Hylton, the court wrote, “When the state law is facially overbroad, we look no further.”
NOTE: Reason to believe charges do not require a conviction. See reason to believe.
NY Penal Law § 220.39: Criminal sale of a controlled substance in the third degree
There are several offenses prohibiting selling drugs in the New York Penal Code. Most require that you sell or attempt to sell a minimum amount of specific types of drugs in order to be prosecuted. You will have committed the crime of criminal sale of a controlled substance in the third degree under New York Penal Code § 220.39 if you knowingly and unlawfully sell drugs as follows:
- A narcotic drug,
- A stimulant weighing at least 1 gram,
- Lysergic acid diethylamide weighing at 1 milligram,
- A hallucinogen weighing at least 25 milligrams,
- A hallucinogenic weighing at least 1 grams, or
- Methadone weighing at least 1/8 of an ounce.
In addition you could be prosecuted for criminal sale of a controlled substance in the third degree if you sell narcotics to someone who is under the age of 21, or you sell a stimulant, hallucinogen, hallucinogenic substance, or lysergic acid diethylamide and you previously have been convicted of a drug offense.